
A few years ago, I found myself sitting across from a sports dietitian, completely perplexed.
At that point in my life, I was on my feet all day working with patients, moving bodies, demonstrating exercises, and lifting heavy loads in the gym. I was tracking my food meticulously, keeping my calories low, pushing my protein higher and higher, and doing everything we are taught to call “disciplined.” Yet clinically, my muscle mass refused to budge.
She took one look at my daily physical output, looked at my food logs, and told me plainly: “Michelle, your job makes you an endurance athlete, and you are literally starving your tissue of carbohydrates.”
I remember staring at her because every standard fitness message insists on fewer carbs, fewer calories, and more sweat. But tissue biology does not care about diet culture. We added three deliberate portions of quality carbohydrates back into my day, timed with my workload, sorted out my electrolyte balance, and within three months my muscle mass took off. People at the gym actually asked what routine I’d switched to. Nothing in my training had changed; my cells just finally had the substrate to build contractile tissue.
This brings me to something I watch happen in my practice almost every Monday.
A client walks into the studio, and I can see the deflation before she even puts her bag down. She stepped on the bathroom scale at 7:00 AM, the number didn’t drop or it crept up by a kilogram, and the whole previous week was immediately written off as a failure. What follows is an immediate spiral of harsh self-criticism: “I was so stupid this weekend,” or “I have no discipline.”
It makes me genuinely sad, because that scale was never a fair physiological measure.
A standard bathroom scale registers a single downward force against a spring. It cannot differentiate between skeletal muscle, bone mineral density, cellular inflammation, or four cups of water retained because sleep was broken or life was stressful. For our grandmothers, that scale was the only domestic tool available. But human physiology is far more complex than total mass, and women are not small men.
Most traditional exercise and nutrition guidelines were modeled on male subjects because they don’t experience monthly hormonal shifts. But female physiology moves through distinct phases every single week, not to mention the massive neurological, pelvic, and musculoskeletal transitions of pregnancy, postpartum recovery, and perimenopause. In the luteal phase—the week before menstruation—our bodies naturally hold onto fluid and mineral salts. If you stand on a bioimpedance scale or measure tissue calipers during that window, the reading will shift simply because hydrated, water-retaining tissue conducts electrical current differently. That is fluid dynamics, not sudden fat gain.
In my practice, when I look at body composition across months, the raw scale weight is the least interesting variable. I look at four things instead:
- Skeletal muscle mass and mechanical progression: Are the joints handling load with integrity? Are you retaining the contractile tissue that supports your spine, hips, and resting metabolic rate?
- Biochemical hydration and nutrition: Drinking plain water all day can actually dilute extracellular sodium and potassium if you aren’t balancing minerals. And if you chronically cut carbohydrates while training hard, the body enters a survival state—it breaks down muscle tissue for amino acids because that is easier than mobilizing stored fat under stress.
- Restorative sleep and nervous system recovery: Poor sleep drives cortisol up, which alters fluid retention, halts tissue repair, and signals the body to hold onto visceral fat.
- Hormonal baseline and blood markers: A simple, routine yearly blood panel through your GP—checking iron, thyroid function, blood cells, and basic metabolic panels—gives you real, objective baseline data over a lifetime, rather than guessing in the dark.
If you are carrying a basket of laundry down the hall and drop a single sock, you don’t throw the whole basket on the floor and give up on clean clothes. You pick up the sock and keep walking.
Yet when a weekend includes wine, late dinners, or missed sessions, the reaction is so often guilt, shame, and punishment. I see my male clients laugh off a heavy weekend and jump straight back into their normal routine on Monday without a second thought. But women carry decades of conditioning telling them they must shrink, often comparing their bodies at forty or fifty to how they looked at twenty, before life, children, careers, and decades of living reshaped their tissues.
Data is just data. A scale reading is no different than the resting heart rate on your watch—one isolated metric across months, not an emotional judgment on who you are.
What would change if the goal was no longer about taking up less space, but giving your body the fuel, load, and rest it actually needs to move well?